[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":209},["ShallowReactive",2],{"compare-charleston-wv-vs-columbus-oh":3},{"a":4,"b":87,"deltas":193,"winners":206},{"slug":5,"name":6,"state_abbr":7,"state_name":8,"population":9,"median_income":10,"median_rent":11,"median_home_value":12,"median_age":13,"poverty_count":14,"poverty_rate":15,"data_year":16,"education":17,"housing":20,"internet":22,"commute":24,"age_distribution":26,"crime":32,"weather":35,"hud":37,"scores":38,"pros":43,"cons":49,"state_cities":50,"nearby_cities":51,"similar_cities":52,"compare_links":77},"charleston-wv","Charleston","WV","West Virginia",48415,58902,870,172800,42.2,7946,16.4,2022,{"hs_graduation_pct":18,"bachelors_pct":19},92.1,43.2,{"home_ownership_pct":21},60.8,{"broadband_pct":23},86.2,{"avg_minutes":25},19.5,{"under18":27,"age18to34":28,"age35to54":29,"age55to64":30,"age65plus":31},18.3,22,25.1,14.6,20.1,{"violent_rate":33,"property_rate":34},6.821541710665259,44.688489968321015,{"avg_temp":36,"rainfall_inches":36,"snowfall_inches":36,"sunny_days":36},null,{"fmr_2br":36,"renter_burden_pct":19},{"affordability":39,"education":40,"crime":41,"weather":36,"livability":42},70,72,43,62,[44,45,46,47,48],"Very affordable cost of living","Highly educated population","Excellent broadband internet access","Short average commute times","Strong homeownership community",[],[],[],[53,58,63,68,73],{"slug":54,"name":55,"state_abbr":56,"population":57,"livability":42},"chicago-il","Chicago","IL",2721914,{"slug":59,"name":60,"state_abbr":61,"population":62,"livability":42},"colorado-springs-co","Colorado Springs","CO",479612,{"slug":64,"name":65,"state_abbr":66,"population":67,"livability":42},"chula-vista-ca","Chula Vista","CA",276103,{"slug":69,"name":70,"state_abbr":71,"population":72,"livability":42},"tempe-az","Tempe","AZ",181005,{"slug":74,"name":75,"state_abbr":66,"population":76,"livability":42},"santa-rosa-ca","Santa Rosa",178221,[78,85],{"slug":79,"name":80,"state_abbr":81,"lat":82,"lon":83,"reason":84},"roanoke-va","Roanoke","VA",37.278458,-79.958174,"Closest city in another state",{"slug":54,"name":55,"state_abbr":56,"reason":86},"Similar overall livability",{"slug":88,"name":89,"state_abbr":90,"state_name":91,"population":92,"median_income":93,"median_rent":94,"median_home_value":95,"median_age":96,"poverty_count":97,"poverty_rate":98,"data_year":16,"education":99,"housing":102,"internet":104,"commute":106,"age_distribution":108,"crime":114,"weather":117,"hud":118,"scores":120,"pros":124,"cons":126,"state_cities":127,"nearby_cities":148,"similar_cities":162,"compare_links":186},"columbus-oh","Columbus","OH","Ohio",902449,62994,1161,212500,32.7,159541,17.7,{"hs_graduation_pct":100,"bachelors_pct":101},90.3,38.3,{"home_ownership_pct":103},44.7,{"broadband_pct":105},91.3,{"avg_minutes":107},23.7,{"under18":109,"age18to34":110,"age35to54":111,"age55to64":112,"age65plus":113},21.9,32.2,24.5,10.6,10.7,{"violent_rate":115,"property_rate":116},0.6967355888440337,11.496137215926556,{"avg_temp":36,"rainfall_inches":36,"snowfall_inches":36,"sunny_days":36},{"fmr_2br":36,"renter_burden_pct":119},42.1,{"affordability":121,"education":122,"crime":123,"weather":36,"livability":40},63,65,89,[45,125,46],"Low crime rate",[],[128,132,136,140,144],{"slug":129,"name":130,"population":131},"cleveland-oh","Cleveland",370365,{"slug":133,"name":134,"population":135},"cincinnati-oh","Cincinnati",308870,{"slug":137,"name":138,"population":139},"toledo-oh","Toledo",269962,{"slug":141,"name":142,"population":143},"akron-oh","Akron",190273,{"slug":145,"name":146,"population":147},"dayton-oh","Dayton",137305,[149,151,153,155,160],{"slug":145,"name":146,"population":147,"distance_km":150},106,{"slug":133,"name":134,"population":135,"distance_km":152},161,{"slug":141,"name":142,"population":143,"distance_km":154},174,{"slug":156,"name":157,"population":158,"distance_km":159},"parma-oh","Parma",80587,188,{"slug":137,"name":138,"population":139,"distance_km":161},193,[163,167,172,177,182],{"slug":164,"name":165,"state_abbr":81,"population":166,"livability":40},"virginia-beach-va","Virginia Beach",457900,{"slug":168,"name":169,"state_abbr":170,"population":171,"livability":40},"lexington-fayette-urban-county-ky","Lexington-Fayette urban county","KY",321276,{"slug":173,"name":174,"state_abbr":175,"population":176,"livability":40},"stamford-ct","Stamford","CT",135413,{"slug":178,"name":179,"state_abbr":180,"population":181,"livability":40},"coral-springs-fl","Coral Springs","FL",133801,{"slug":183,"name":184,"state_abbr":61,"population":185,"livability":40},"arvada-co","Arvada",123066,[187,189,192],{"slug":129,"name":130,"state_abbr":90,"reason":188},"Largest city in same state",{"slug":5,"name":6,"state_abbr":7,"lat":190,"lon":191,"reason":84},38.348692,-81.632324,{"slug":164,"name":165,"state_abbr":81,"reason":86},{"population":194,"median_income":195,"median_rent":196,"median_home_value":197,"median_age":198,"hs_graduation_pct":199,"bachelors_pct":200,"broadband_pct":201,"home_ownership_pct":202,"commute_time_avg":203,"violent_crime_rate":204,"property_crime_rate":205,"avg_annual_temp":36,"sunny_days":36,"avg_snowfall_inches":36,"avg_rainfall_inches":36},-854034,-4092,-291,-39700,9.5,1.7999999999999972,4.900000000000006,-5.099999999999994,16.099999999999994,-4.199999999999999,6.1248061218212255,33.192352752394456,{"affordability":207,"education":207,"crime":208,"weather":36,"livability":208},"a","b",1779600576037]